Atlantic Pizzeria & Restuarant - Reviews

Great Restaurant and fast service. Great food, lots of choices. Unlike some local pizza, not greasy at all and many toppings to choose from. Pasta dishes are large and have a good amount of ingedients. This is the place to go for pizza in the area. The crust is thin and well done.

A Great place for Pizza in Atlantic City. Crust is always crisp, never soggy. Not just once, but every time I order a pizza from Atlantic, it is finger licking, mouth watering, scrumptious deliciousness. That's a tall order considering they are working with gf crust. On top of the best pie in at least Maine, New Hampshire, Massachusetts , they use seperate utensils to make the pizza. They are very contience about cross contaminating. To boot, the owner, Scotty and his crew are very pleasant and accommodating.

I love eating here when Im in Stamford. The food is really good and fresh, especially the pizza. Its the fresh ingredients.

I have always been dredding going to get furniture but not here. These guys are great. They treat you with respect and give you the best price at the same time. Thanks guys

Great Service, Great food Really enjoyed this place - attentive staff - good location, food tasty and well presented - reasonable prices - would return .

Could be the best Pizzeria on Long Island, if not NY. I am a pizza lover. I LOVE pizza. I've been in over 200 pizzerias in my time, but I got to tell you.. This pizzeria is It. Atlantic Pizzeria has it all. Their crust is to kill for. I highly recommend trying their layered eggplant pizza and their buffalo pizza, they are two of my personal favorites

I'm new to long island, I lived in brooklyn all my life. now living in baldwin, i realized that it will be harder than i expected to find a pizzeria that is as good as
back in brooklyn.. i tried two different places in baldwin and it was just pizza, nothing special... nothing like home.. I found that Freeport has more pizzerias than
baldwin so i was sure i would find a good one. after trying three pizzerias in this town, i began to lose hope. while i was in Seven11 complaining about pizza, someone
said i should try Atlantic Pizzeria which was pretty much right across the street. so i said what the hell, cant be worse than the cardboard slices ive tried so far on
this island and walked over.... Let Me Tell You, it was an experience. Probably my BEST long island experience so far, aside from being allowed to make a right at a red
light. before i even got in I noticed the blues music playing outside, unusual i thought, but unique. when i got inside, the countergirl laughed as my jaw dropped at
the sight of the place. the decor was incredible. i loved the place and i hadnt even had a slice yet! I ordered a regular slice and took a seat. When I took a bite i
felt like I was home again. the slice was perfect. it had great taste and and the most perfect crunch. when i took another bite, i realized it wasnt as good as my
brooklyn pizza but it was BETTER! they put something on their crust that makes their slices unlike any other pizzerias. I knew before i walked in this place was
unique.. Unbelievable pizza, awesome atmosphere. not five, but TEN stars to you Atlantic Pizzeria!

This could be one of the best slice of pizza I ever had.. what place a truly
Italian Pizzeria. I haven't seen this type of pizza joint since my old days in
Brooklyn. I never write anything about people or places but I was soo impress
with this place, I had to. Atlantic Pizzeria I thank you, for taking me back to
the good old days. Anyone who hasn't tried this place... they should. Their
pizza is to kill for their crust is amazing.

Yummy Yum Yum....... Goody Good Food....... Tonight I had the eggplant parmesan, and let me tell you it was second to none, I don't think I could have done a better job myself. I also ordered a large Greek salad, and let me tell you, they put plenty of feta cheese , olives, and loads of other vegetables into that salad. It's just not some lettuce and a couple of carrots scrapings that a rabbit would turn his nose up to, like you getting so many other restaurants. The decor of the restaurant is simple, but effective and the staff all more than friendly and very helpful. When I want Italian , this is the only restaurant I would go to.

Lasagna is a favorite dish of Garfield's, but not necessarily of mine. I'm not particularly sure why, but I've never been a huge fan of it. Looking to try something different, I gave the Lasgana from Atlantic Pizzeria a shot. It was a good meal! The cheese was molten when I first got it. Instead of ground beef, the meat in the dish was thick and juicy. The portion size was huge, certainly your dollar's worth. Is it the best Lasagna in Freeport? It very well could be, given that I rarely eat it! But, whatever it was, it was certainly a good meal for something out of my usual flavor.